Follow the Nordic model for tackling prostitution. Criminalization and economic and criminal punishment of prostitutes. This is what the European Parliament asked 27 with 234 votes, 175 against and 122 abstentions for the report, which supports the way to abolish prostitution, although it has no legislative effect because it has the competence of this regulation. member countries.
One of the key points of the report is that it calls for the sanctioning of clients of prostitution and the decriminalization of those who practice it, as they do not do so freely in the vast majority of cases. “Calls on Member States to ensure that they do not request, receive or accept a sexual act from a person in exchange for payment, the promise of payment, the giving of a benefit in kind or the promise of such a benefit,” the text reads.
Promoters know that this is not enough and that a support network should be created for women who find themselves in this situation through “exit programs”, which means financial provision for things that should not be caused by leaving the activity. by the writer of the report. According to him, financial assistance is a formula so that the punishment of prostitutes does not lead them to practice prostitution in situations of greater marginalization, which is one of the arguments of the opponents of the initiative, because they consider it to blame women.
Will this make prostitutes more empowered? – asked the journalists Amelia Tiganus, a survivor of prostitution, writer and feminist. “I think the opposite. “Women are subjects of the law and should have access to institutions to exercise their rights,” she replied, referring to the need to access job offers, professional opportunities or budget items.
“Buying a woman’s body is not allowed,” summarizes German socialist Maria Neuchl, who claims that people engaged in prostitution start from inequality and instability. “It’s not normal to say: I can be a prostitute or a prostitute,” she argues, the criteria of some groups that have defended the concept of “sex workers”.
“Prostitution is not a job. As political leaders, but as members of society, we must not close our eyes to the suffering of people who suffer from prostitution,” the PP spokesperson argued in the debate: “I hope that member states do everything to ensure that prostitutes in this “The Nordic model is ours,” said Rosa Estaras from the Balearic Islands.
division into groups
“We need to listen to those who are free to choose this work,” defended the Liberals, a spokesman for Renew, who believed the report should focus on “human rights and sexual health”, for which he called for a vote against the report.
The division was also evident in the Greens. “We want to do everything we can to ensure that the EU can fight sexual exploitation, but we don’t want to go so far as to say that all sex work is gender-based violence,” said spokesperson Terry Reinke. However, her colleague Alyssa Kuhnk wore an “I stand with survivors” T-shirt during the debate and called for a “yes” vote for the report.
ERC MEP (also part of the Greens) Diana Riba, who voted for the report, supported the minority position – a procedure allowed in the negotiation of texts by the European Chamber – in which she defends that she rejects the use of terms such as “prostitution” when we understand that ” They imply value judgments, carry connotations of crime and immorality, and stigmatize a marginalized community.” “People who sell sexual services prefer the term ‘sex worker’ because the use of ‘prostitute’ contributes to social exclusion, as well as health, legal and social in terms of access to services,” the dissent said.
Survivors: ‘Buying sex is an act of violence’
“Sexual intercourse cannot be the subject of an employment contract even when there is a contract, because it is always a violation of sexual freedom,” argues María Eugenia Rodríguez Palopi, from Sumari (left).
The European Chamber’s bet is in line with a law promoted by the Socialists in Spain (endorsed by the PP and which split Unidas Podemos), but which fell on deaf ears due to electoral advances. The split within the leftist forces was similar to what happened in Spain, where Unidas Podemos and the ERC broke away from this position.
“Buying sex is an act of violence,” replied Saga Brodersen, a prostitution survivor and director of Not Your Whore in Sweden. “We cannot continue to think that women exist in such a way that men ejaculate. We’re going to be able to enjoy our sexuality to enjoy the same goals as men when they eroticize violence against women,” said Amelia Tiganus.
Source: El Diario